A US lawsuit has been filed against K-pop group NewJeans concerning their song 'How Sweet,' with four songwriters alleging plagiarism of their demo track 'One of Kind.' They claim the melody and composition of 'How Sweet' replicate their work and are seeking royalty distribution. The lawsuit names NewJeans, their agency ADOR, and parent company HYBE, escalating the controversy.
NewJeans 'How Sweet' Plagiarism Lawsuit: The Specific Allegations
According to Billboard, four songwriters, including Audrey N. Amaokost, have filed a lawsuit against NewJeans, ADOR, and HYBE, alleging that 'How Sweet' plagiarizes their demo song 'One of Kind.' The plaintiffs claim they previously offered a top-line melody to NewJeans that was not used, and that 'How Sweet' bears a striking resemblance to it. The lawsuit specifically points to the identical key (B flat minor) and tempo shared by both songs, with a particular focus on a 31-note melodic sequence that is claimed to be highly similar. This detailed comparison of musical elements is expected to be a key point in the legal proceedings.
What is 'How Sweet' and How is the Plagiarism Controversy Unfolding?
Related Articles
'How Sweet,' released in May 2024, is a hit track by NewJeans, known for its Miami bass-inspired hip-hop style and catchy rhythm. It achieved significant global success, charting at #15 on the Billboard Global 200 and #7 on the Global Excl. US chart, and was recognized by Rolling Stone as one of the best songs of 2024. This critical acclaim makes the current plagiarism allegations particularly disheartening for fans. The production team behind 'How Sweet' has vehemently denied the claims, stating they are 'groundless.' ADOR has also announced its intention to actively respond to the lawsuit, supporting the production team's stance.
NewJeans' Current Situation and the Impact of the Plagiarism Lawsuit
NewJeans is currently navigating a challenging period marked by an internal dispute over their exclusive contract, with recent news of member Danielle's potential departure further impacting the group. The remaining members are reportedly in negotiations for their return to ADOR and are believed to be emotionally and mentally strained. Amidst these complex internal issues, the plagiarism lawsuit raises concerns about its potential impact on NewJeans' future activities. The group is reportedly coordinating a return to a four-member lineup, excluding Danielle. Plagiarism is a sensitive issue in the creative world, and many are hoping for clarity and resolution regarding this matter.
NewJeans Plagiarism Lawsuit: What Happens Next?
The lawsuit over NewJeans' 'How Sweet' is likely to proceed through a legal battle, with the outcome potentially having a significant impact on the group's image and future career. The songwriters are demanding royalty distribution based on the alleged specific melodic similarities, while NewJeans' side maintains the claims are 'groundless' and has vowed legal action. Determining musical plagiarism involves scientific and technical analysis by the court, which can be a lengthy process. If plagiarism is confirmed, NewJeans, HYBE, and ADOR could face legal and financial repercussions. Therefore, close attention is being paid to the intense legal proceedings and their potential consequences for NewJeans' career. Legal judgments can vary based on individual circumstances, so consulting with relevant legal professionals is advisable.
For more details, check the original source below.
